Piggyback Loan vs PMI: Which is the Better Option?

Piggyback loan pictureAre you considering purchasing a home and feeling overwhelmed by the various financing options? The ongoing discussion about piggyback loans versus private mortgage insurance (PMI) has left many potential homebuyers unsure about the best path forward.

Don't know which route to take on your journey to homeownership? This article explores the intricacies of piggyback loans and PMI to help you navigate the complex world of mortgage options.

Whether you are a first-time buyer or an experienced investor, it's crucial to understand the advantages and disadvantages of each option to make an informed decision that aligns with your financial goals and aspirations for homeownership.

Understanding Piggyback Loans

A piggyback loan involves obtaining two mortgages when purchasing a home. The primary mortgage covers 80% of the purchase price, while the piggyback second mortgage covers 10-20% as a substitute for a down payment. This arrangement avoids the need for PMI while enabling you to buy with less than a 20% down payment.

For instance, when buying a $300,000 home, you might secure a $240,000 first mortgage covering 80% of the value. A $60,000 piggyback second mortgage would cover the remaining 20% down payment. Consequently, you make two separate monthly mortgage payments.

Advantages of Piggyback Loans

Some benefits of opting for a piggyback loan structure include:

  1. Avoiding PMI: By keeping the first loan under 80% of the home, you skip the need for private mortgage insurance, which can add hundreds to your monthly payments.
  2. Potentially lower rates: Since the first mortgage may qualify for better interest rates, you might enjoy more favorable terms than a single loan with PMI.
  3. Smaller down payment: With piggyback loans, you may need only 10-15% down instead of the traditional 20%.
  4. Faster equity: Making two monthly mortgage payments helps you build home equity more quickly.
  5. Purchase higher-priced homes: Piggyback loans enable you to buy more expensive properties by reducing the down payment requirement.

Disadvantages of Piggyback Loans

However, there are some drawbacks to consider with piggyback home loans:

  1. Higher monthly costs: Having two mortgage payments instead of one increases your overall housing expenses.
  2. More challenging qualification: When two loans are involved, lenders often scrutinize borrowers more rigorously, making a good credit score essential.
  3. Refinancing challenges: Refinancing or modifying piggyback mortgages can be more challenging than a single loan.
  4. Closing costs and fees: Expect higher expenses due to the need for two separate loans.
  5. Debt-to-income factors: The presence of two payments may impact your debt-to-income ratios when qualifying for the loan.

In summary, while piggyback loans provide an alternative method of financing a home with less cash down, they come with trade-offs that should be carefully weighed against the PMI alternative.

Understanding Private Mortgage Insurance

Most lenders require private mortgage insurance if your down payment is less than 20% of the purchase price. PMI protects the lender in case of default on a mortgage with low down payment equity.

With PMI, you pay an additional monthly premium to your regular mortgage payment. This premium is typically around 0.5-1% of the total loan amount annually. For example, an OA$200,000 loan amounts to an extra $1000-2000 per year.

PMI remains in place until you have built up 20% equity in the home. FHA loans stay for the entire loan term, while conventional loans allow you to cancel PMI once you reach 20% equity through appreciation or extra payments.

Advantages of Private Mortgage Insurance

Some potential benefits of opting for private mortgage insurance are:

  1. Lower payment requirements: With PMI, you may need only 3-5% down, requiring less cash upfront.
  2. More straightforward home buying process: Dealing with just one loan simplifies the qualification, approval, and closing processes.
  3. No second loan or lien: Only the primary lender has a lien on the property with PMI.
  4. More accessible to modify or refinance: PMI avoids the complexity of managing two mortgages, simplifying future changes to your mortgage.
  5. Lower upfront costs: PMI involves fewer fees and closing costs compared to having two loans.

Disadvantages of Private Mortgage Insurance

However, there are some drawbacks to consider with PMI:

  1. Monthly PMI premiums: This additional mortgage payment does not contribute to building equity in your home.
  2. Prepayment penalties: You may incur fees if you pay below 80% loan-to-value too quickly to cancel PMI.
  3. No interest deduction: PMI premiums are not tax-deductible, unlike mortgage interest.
  4. Loan term requirements: FHA loans require PMI for the entire loan term, while conventional loans allow you to cancel PMI once you reach 20% equity.
  5. Refinancing requirement: If appreciation alone does not get you to 20% equity, you may need to refinance to remove PMI.

In summary, PMI offers a trade-off of lower upfront costs for higher monthly payments. It's a more straightforward option logistically but has some long-term drawbacks.

Comparing Piggyback Loans and PMI

Choosing between a piggyback loan and PMI depends on your situation and priorities. Here are some key factors to consider:

  1. Upfront costs: PMI has lower upfront fees, while piggybacks require two closing costs.
  2. Monthly payments: Piggybacks result in higher monthly payments due to two mortgages, while PMI involves a single monthly premium.
  3. Interest rates: Piggyback loans may offer better rates on the primary mortgage, but the second mortgage typically has a higher rate. PMI involves a single interest rate.
  4. Credit score requirements: Piggyback loans typically require higher credit scores, while PMI may be possible with lower scores.
  5. Home price limits: Jumbo loan piggybacks allow you to buy higher-priced homes than conforming loan limits with PMI.
  6. Long-term costs: Piggyback loans help build equity faster through two payments, while PMI leads to increased total interest paid over time.
  7. Ease of financing: Getting one loan with PMI is more straightforward than managing two mortgages.
  8. Future refinancing: Piggyback loans complicate refinancing, while PMI allows refinancing as a single loan more quickly.

Run the numbers for your mortgage amount and down payment, and consult mortgage professionals to understand the total costs. This will help determine whether a piggyback loan or PMI matches your home-buying plans and financial situation.

Suitability for Piggyback Loans

Piggyback loans are best suited for specific borrowers:

  1. Strong credit: You will need scores around 700+ to qualify for two combined mortgages.
  2. Buying a higher-priced home: Piggyback loans enable purchasing properties above conforming mortgage limits.
  3. Avoiding PMI: Consider piggyback loans if you prefer not to pay extra monthly PMI premiums.
  4. Plan to pay down quickly: Paying off debt faster helps reduce the higher costs associated with piggyback loans over time.
  5. Desire lower rates: The split structure of piggyback loans may allow for a better rate on the primary balance.

Piggyback loans appeal to savvy borrowers seeking alternative financing options who understand the trade-offs.

Suitability for Private Mortgage Insurance

PMI may be more suitable for some borrowers:

  1. Need for lower down payment: PMI requires as little as 3-5% down, requiring less cash upfront.
  2. Lower credit scores: PMI may be available at lower scores that would qualify for a piggyback loan.
  3. Plan to move again soon: Avoiding higher fees with PMI can be beneficial if you don't want to stay in the home long term.
  4. I prefer a more straightforward process. Managing one loan with PMI is more superficial than dealing with two piggyback mortgages.
  5. Don't higher monthly costs: The PMI premium may be worth it to avoid higher upfront needs.

First-time homebuyers often choose PMI to take advantage of purchasing sooner with less cash down.

Pros and Cons of Piggyback Home Loans

Opting for a piggyback home loan has several advantages and some drawbacks. One of the main advantages is the ability to avoid paying for private mortgage insurance (PMI), which is particularly beneficial for those who cannot afford a 20% down payment. Additionally, a piggyback loan can reduce the primary mortgage amount and potentially secure a better interest rate.

However, piggyback loans typically have higher interest rates than traditional mortgages. MoSinceiggyback loans usually involve obtaining a second mortgage from another lender; borrowers may encounter more complex paperwork and higher closing costs.

Additionally, in the event of a housing market slowdown or decline in property values, borrowers with a piggyback loan may be at a greater risk of negative equity. Therefore, it is crucial for individuals to carefully evaluate the pros and cons before opting for a piggyback home loan.

Seeking Advice from a Mortgage Professional

Deciding between a piggyback loan and PMI depends on your financial situation, credit profile, and home-buying plans. Consulting with an experienced mortgage professional is the best way to understand the total costs and determine the most advantageous option for your circumstances.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, both piggyback loans and PMI offer distinct advantages and disadvantages. While piggyback loans allow borrowers to avoid paying PMI and potentially secure a lower interest rate on the primary mortgage, they also come with higher upfront costs. They may be more challenging to qualify for. 

On the other hand, PMI provides a more straightforward and accessible option for borrowers who may not have sufficient funds for a large down payment or high credit scores, but it can lead to higher monthly payments over time.

Ultimately, the decision between a piggyback loan and PMI depends on individual financial circumstances, long-term goals, and preferences. Borrowers must carefully weigh the pros and cons of each option before making a decision that best suits their needs.

Termination of Conventional Mortgage Insurance
MGIC rate cards
Mortgage Insurance Coverage Requirements

Recommended Reading

Avoid PMI with a Piggyback Second Mortgage or HELOC
Piggyback Mortgage Calculator with Payment
PMI in a Mortgage: The Pros and Cons
How Much is PMI on a Conventional Loan?